Monday, November 23, 2020

The World After Covid Could Shake Up Business Flights: A smaller, more price-sensitive corporate market is likely to become a new battleground between low-cost and legacy airlines

The Wall Street Journal
By Jon Sindreu
November 22, 2020 10:18 am ET

The aviation crisis triggered by 9/11 eventually made budget carriers the undisputed leaders in leisure flights. Covid-19 could give them the keys to business travel.

Three major U.S. carriers, United Airlines, Delta Air Lines and Southwest Airlines, recently warned that sales are deteriorating as the winter season approaches. But demand for cheap holiday flights could bounce back once a vaccine is distributed, as it did when lockdowns were eased this summer.

Business travel is another story. Airline executives believe that increased use of videoconferencing could take a permanent 15% bite out of the market. The battle for this shrinking pie could reshape the most profitable part of their industry.

In a recent survey, Barclays found that more than half of Americans who flew for business in 2019 expect a 20% or greater fall in such travel after the pandemic. Technology was the most commonly cited reason, with budgetary restraint in second place. Data by business-spending management firm Coupa Software shows that, among the few tickets bought by corporate accounts in the third quarter, the average fare was 45% cheaper than a year earlier.

Greater price-sensitivity in corporate bookings is an opening for budget airlines. Southwest is already increasing its presence at Chicago O’Hare, a hub claimed by both United and American Airlines. It is also threatening United at Houston and American at Miami.

“We’re positioned now in the corporate market to be a real player,” Southwest Chief Executive Gary Kelly told analysts last month.

Southwest has already spent a decade expanding in main airports, particularly after acquiring AirTran Airways in 2011. In recent years, its network connectivity has become more concentrated in top airports, including legacy hubs in Atlanta and Washington, D.C., a data analysis reveals.

“We’re positioned now in the corporate market to be a real player,” Southwest Chief Executive Gary Kelly told analysts last month.

Southwest has already spent a decade expanding in main airports, particularly after acquiring AirTran Airways in 2011. In recent years, its network connectivity has become more concentrated in top airports, including legacy hubs in Atlanta and Washington, D.C., a data analysis reveals.

Covid-19 has changed the picture by leaving even the busiest airports with plenty of space. Budget airlines are well placed to fill it because they have more cash and less debt.

Ultralow-cost carriers like Spirit, Allegiant, Ryanair and Wizz Air might be wary of assaulting business hubs, where expenses are higher. They could instead focus on their traditional tactic: squeezing hollowed-out secondary airports. But Southwest caters to a slightly higher-cost segment. It even has business fares with extra perks. In 2019, 35% of its revenue came from companies, Barclays estimates, which is in between mainline operators at 50% and Spirit and Allegiant at 10%.

JetBlue, with its successful premium Mint product, is another U.S. low-cost player well positioned to nibble away at this market.

In Europe, London-based easyJet champions this “hybrid” strategy. It combines low costs with offers such as extra legroom on certain seats and a focus on big business cities. Before Covid-19, it had increased its connectivity in hubs like Paris’s Charles de Gaulle and Amsterdam’s Schiphol, at the expense of the rest of its network. So far, though, easyJet has chosen to retrench rather than attack, because its balance sheet isn’t pristine.

A risk for hybrid players is that their own leisure business could be undercut by ultralow-cost operators. Those rivals are now waiving change fees—one of Southwest’s signature customer benefits.

Regardless, flying is no longer a two-stream market. U.S. legacy airlines themselves have spent years phasing out first-class cabins and segmenting customers into a wider range of products. The strategy made money, but may also have whetted the appetite of corporate clients for cheaper options.

“It’s a deterioration of the premium product,” said Pere Suau-S├ínchez, a lecturer in air-transport management at the U.K.’s Cranfield University. “A lot of the boost in ‘premium economy’ seats is from companies that don’t want to pay for business class.”

Even a small loss of corporate business at key airports could destroy the connectivity of legacy players’ carefully crafted networks, making some international routes unprofitable. After a lucrative period of truce, the airline industry may be ripe for a new war.

3 comments:

  1. Flu-policy-driven lost earnings by businesses and individuals along with reduced tax and fee revenue hitting airports and municipalities makes predicting the future difficult. The 911 event was nothing like this.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The take away is Southwest can't un-ring their bell. It's only going to get worse before it gets better.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What about the global and domestic excess capacity of the industry as a whole post COVID? Demand will not go back to where it was pre-pandemic. Some airlines will have to go. United? American? The only reasonable bet is on well-managed domestic airlines like Southwest, which do not depend on the iffy international market.

    ReplyDelete