NTSB Identification: ERA12FA566
14 CFR Part 91: General Aviation
Accident occurred Monday, September 17, 2012 in Crane Hill, AL
Aircraft: MOONEY M20M, registration: N1085A
Injuries: 2 Fatal.
This is preliminary information, subject to change, and may contain errors. Any errors in this report will be corrected when the final report has been completed. NTSB investigators either traveled in support of this investigation or conducted a significant amount of investigative work without any travel, and used data obtained from various sources to prepare this aircraft accident report.
On September 17, 2012, about 1400 central daylight time, a Mooney M20M, N1085A, was substantially damaged when it impacted terrain in Crane Hill, Alabama. The private pilot and the passenger were fatally injured. Instrument meteorological conditions prevailed, and the airplane was operating on an instrument flight rules flight plan from Destin-Fort Walton Beach Airport (DTS), Destin, Florida, to Sumner County Regional Airport (M33), Gallatin, Tennessee. The personal flight was conducted under the provisions of 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91.
According to preliminary air traffic control information provided by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), at 1317, while airplane was at 13,000 feet, the pilot requested information about conditions at 15,000 feet. The center controller responded that there was no icing, "but a lot of course deviations with precipitation ahead." The pilot requested and was granted a climb to 15,000 feet.
At 1325, the pilot was told to contact the center's next sector controller, and upon doing so, that controller advised him of moderate to extreme precipitation for about the next 90 miles along the route of flight. The pilot subsequently stated that he was looking at ADS-B (Automatic Dependent Surveillance-Broadcast), and needed to deviate for several miles before turning back to the north. The controller approved 10 degrees' right and left deviation, and direct to M33 when able.
At 1334, the controller advised the pilot of moderate to extreme precipitation at his 12 to 1 o'clock position about 12 miles ahead. The pilot requested another 10 degrees' deviation to the left, and the controller approved deviations left and right, and direct to M33 when able.
At 1336, the pilot advised the controller that he was turning the airplane to 320 degrees, which the controller acknowledged.
At 1354, the controller issued the pilot a radio frequency change, to which, the pilot responded, "Unable, we're battling some pretty bad" (end of transmission.)
At 1359:01, the controller called the pilot, who responded with, "MAYDAY (unintelligible) MAY eight five alpha MAYDAY MAYDAY." There were no further transmissions from the airplane.
A witness stated that, at the time of the accident, it was raining "like crazy," but with no thunder. He heard an engine noise; it "sounded like he had power, then [I] heard a 'thud.'" When the witness arrived at the accident site, the airplane's cabin was on fire.
The airplane first impacted rolling pastureland in the vicinity of 33 degrees, 58.58 minutes north latitude, 087 degrees, 07.04 west longitude, at an elevation of about 560 feet.
A ground imprint of the airplane's tail commenced about 5 feet beyond an undamaged 5-foot fence post. The ground imprint was consistent with the airplane having impacted the ground flat and upright, with the landing gear up. Airplane fragments were located along an approximately 225-foot debris path, heading about 010 degrees magnetic, with the cabin area and still-attached engine located near the end of the debris path. Although vegetation was pushed over in many spots along the debris path, there was a lack of ground scaring between the first ground impact and where the cabin came to rest.
Both wings and the tail section were separated from the airplane and were not burned, and there were no soot streaks on any fuselage components to indicate an in-flight fire. The aft portion of the main fuselage behind the passenger seats was unburned and crushed downward. The roof and sidewalls of the cabin area were missing, with the rest of the cabin charred forward of the supplemental oxygen bottle that was located just behind the aft cabin bulkhead. The oxygen bottle, mounted horizontally with the cap pointed forward, was also charred in the cap area.
All flight control surfaces were accounted for at the accident scene; however, due to the extensive fracturing of the airplane and subsequent fire, flight control continuity could not be confirmed.
One propeller blade was found separated from the hub at the initial impact point, and the hub, with the two remaining propeller blades, was found separated from the engine about 75 feet beyond the first blade. One propeller blade exhibited extensive curling and bending, the other two blades exhibited torsional bending, and all blades had leading edge burnishing and chordwise scratching.
The engine could not be examined due to extensive fire and impact damage; however, the starter ring exhibited rotational fracturing.
No airplane recording devices could be found in the wreckage.
Nancy and Gary Cohen
Tanya Long-Garro/Reflections by Tanya
Dr. Gary D. COHEN
Obituary

COHEN, Dr. Gary D.
Age 61 of Hendersonville. Passed away with Nancy, his wife of 36 years,
on Monday, September 17, 2012. He was preceded in death by his father,
Jack Cohen. Survived by his children, Ben Cohen, Grace (Adam) Veenker,
and Melissa Kate Cohen; grandchildren, Steven and Jonah Veenker; mother,
Johnnie Cohen; sister, Cynthia Cohen. Dr. Cohen was a graduate of UT
Memphis and St. Louis University. He was the founder and President of
Smile Construction, Inc. A member of and Deacon at the First Baptist
Church in Hendersonville, he also founded the Nashville Chapter of the
Seattle Study Club. Dr. Cohen loved the outdoors, hunting, fishing, and
flying, but mostly, his grandchildren. Visitation will be held at
Hendersonville First Baptist Church Friday, September 21st from 4-8
p.m., and Saturday, September 22nd from 10 a.m. until service time at 3
p.m. In lieu of flowers, donations may be made to The Cumberland Crisis
Pregnancy Center, Hendersonville First Baptist Church or Tennessee
Baptist Children’s Home. COLE & GARRETT FUNERAL HOME,
Hendersonville, TN (615) 824-8605.
http://www.legacy.com/guestbook
http://www.legacy.com/obituary
Dr. Nancy Norris COHEN
Obituary

COHEN, Dr. Nancy Norris
Age 60 of Hendersonville. Passed away with Gary, her husband of 36
years, on September 17, 2012. She was preceded in death by her parents,
Ben and Ruth Norris. Survived by her children, Ben Cohen, Grace (Adam)
Veenker, and Melissa Kate Cohen; grandchildren, Steven and Jonah
Veenker; sister, Jo Norris (Buddy) Palmore and nephew, Ben Palmore. She
was a graduate of the University of Tennessee College of Pharmacy, and
was a Pharmacist at Perkin’s Drugs in Gallatin. She was a member of
First Baptist Church of Hendersonville, where she founded the Women’s
Ministry and taught Sunday School. Nancy was a true lady who loved to
shop and entertain. She loved her grandsons, and was like a mother to
all who knew her. Visitation will be held at Hendersonville First
Baptist Church Friday, September 21st from 4-8 p.m., and Saturday,
September 22nd from 10 a.m. until service time at 3 p.m. In lieu of
flowers, donations may be made to The Cumberland Crisis Pregnancy
Center, Hendersonville First Baptist Church, or the Tennessee Baptist
Children’s Home. COLE & GARRETT FUNERAL HOME, Hendersonville, TN
(615) 824-8605.
http://www.legacy.com/obituary
http://www.legacy.com/guestbook
Members of the Hendersonville and Gallatin communities are mourning the loss of orthodontist Gary Cohen and his wife, Nancy, who were killed Monday when their small-engine plane crashed near Jasper, Ala.
The two were returning from a weekend vacation in Destin, Fla., and leave behind three adult children and two grandchildren.
Funeral services will be Saturday at 3 p.m. at First Baptist Church Hendersonville. Visitation will be Friday at the church from 4-8 p.m. and Saturday from 10 a.m. until time of service.
Word of the couple’s death spread quickly through the social networking site Facebook Monday night even though officials hadn’t officially released their names.
On Tuesday, the Hendersonville office of Cohen’s Smile Construction was closed. A note outside the building on Springhouse Court asked for privacy while staff members grieved.
“Out of respect for Dr. Cohen’s family, friends and staff, we are asking that all news media refrain from coming into the building,” the note read. “We appreciate your concern, but please allow us to grieve!”
Dr. Gary Cohen, 61, also had satellite offices in Gallatin and White House.
The couple’s small-engine plane went down at around 2:20 p.m. Monday about 25 miles northwest of Birmingham near the small town of Jasper, Ala., according to Mark Persall with the Cullman County Sheriff’s Office. He said his agency was the first on the scene of the crash and that the wreckage was still burning when rescue workers arrived.
Persall said officials with the Federal Aviation Administration arrived within hours of the crash and were continuing their investigation on Wednesday. National Transportation Safety Board officials were also investigating, he added.
He said the plane broke into hundreds of small pieces and created a debris field of 80-150 yards.
Although federal officials will determine the cause of the crash, Persall said he does believe it’s weather-related.
“We were having some heavy bands of rain [on Monday],” he said. “Steady downpours just came in rainbands. The weather was really terrible for small aircraft. There’s no visibility at all in conditions like that.”
According to the Cullman County Times, the National Weather Service recorded 3-5 inches of rain across Cullman County on Monday.
Persall said his office was told that a distress call was made from the plane.
The Mooney M20 single-propeller aircraft took off Sept. 17 from Destin-Fort Walton Beach airport at 12:44 p.m. and was scheduled to arrive at Sumner County Regional Airport at 3:34 p.m., according to FlightAware, a website that tracks flights. The flight’s path shows it reversed direction somewhere over northern Alabama and began heading south.
FAA records show the plane is registered to SC Leasing LLC. That entity is owned by the Cohens, who kept the plane in a hangar at the Gallatin airport, said Sumner County Regional Airport Administrator Steve Sudbury.
Sudbury said he knew Gary Cohen to be a “perfectionist” and a “very meticulous person,” especially when it came to his plane.
“It’s a sad day for aviation in the Sumner community; we don’t have many plane crashes,” he said. “Gary was a great guy, very personable, always had a smile on his face.”
Cohen had filed a flight plan, Sudbury said, so airport officials were expecting him to arrive Monday. However, it became clear from radio communications that the couple was in trouble.
“He was in contact with the Atlanta tower, and evidently, at some point after the first point of notification, later called in a mayday,” he said.
Cullman County Coroner Steve Rodgers said he expected federal officials to let him release the bodies from the forensics laboratory in Huntsville, Ala., on Wednesday. The couple had not been officially identified by this newspaper’s deadline on Wednesday. Rodgers said there have been three fatal plane crashes in the northern Alabama area in three days.
“Three crashes in three days, that’s unheard of for our area,” said the coroner, who services a large area in northern Alabama. “That has hampered our progress.”
A community grieves
Those who knew the couple say the Hendersonville and Gallatin communities have suffered a great loss.
Nancy Cohen, 60, worked as a pharmacist at Perkins Drugs in Gallatin for 12 years, according to former owner Ferrell Haile, who retired in January.
“She was such an asset to our patients,” Haile said. “She was compassionate, but she also knew how to have fun. They both had a strong faith they lived and walked. They were the radiation of Jesus Christ.”
Gary Cohen put braces on each of Hendersonville dentist Brandon Hodge’s three children.
“He was a wonderful man who truly cared for his patients and followed them through their lives,” said Hodge, who was also a friend of the Cohens. “Gary had a zeal for life. He was always up for new adventures. He and Nancy had a love for one another that was evident every time I was around them. Going to dinner with them was like double-dating with teenagers.”
Bruce Chesser, senior pastor at First Baptist Church Hendersonville, also recalled a fun-loving couple. The Cohens had been members of FBCH for 24 years.
“There’s no telling how many children have straight teeth because of Gary Cohen,” said Chesser, whose daily email on Tuesday informed the 8,000-member church of the couple’s death. “They were gregarious, giving people,” he said, recounting how Gary Cohen often rode around on Sunday morning in a golf cart greeting church members.
“The shock of healthy, vibrant people their age – the death of both – there’s where the punch in the gut to the community comes from,” he said.
According to the Smile Construction website, Dr. Cohen graduated from the College of Dentistry at the University of Tennessee. He then worked as a general dentist for five years before entering an orthodontic residency at St. Louis University. He completed the residency training in 1983.
Cohen’s staff members released a statement Tuesday on the Smile Construction Facebook page:
“Dr. Gary Cohen provided excellent orthodontic care for all those who needed it. He set the highest standards for himself, his staff and patients. During this transition period we will honor his memory by ensuring those standards are maintained,” the statement reads.
“We have the support of the Hendersonville area dental community and numerous Board Certified Orthodontists who will be helping to ensure Dr. Cohen's standard and continuity of care is upheld.
In honor of Dr. Cohen, we will continue to care for his patients and maintain client services reflecting the Smile Construction mission statement of providing the highest quality orthodontic care in a warm and caring environment.”
Source: http://www.tennessean.com
Gary and Nancy Cohen, a couple known throughout Sumner County
as shepherds of the community, died Monday when the small plane they
were flying home from a weekend on the Florida panhandle crashed in
Alabama.
He was 61. She was 60.
Gary Cohen issued a weather-related mayday call from his
blue-and-white Mooney M20 at about 2:20 p.m. Monday, said Mark Persall
of the Cullman County Sheriff’s Office.
FAA records show the plane is registered to SC Leasing LLC. That
entity is owned by the Cohens, who kept the plane in a hangar at the
Gallatin airport, said Sumner County Regional Airport Administrator
Steve Sudbury.
Sudbury said he knew Gary Cohen to be a “perfectionist” and a “very meticulous person,” especially when it came to his plane.
Cohen had filed a flight plan, Sudbury said, so airport officials
knew to expect him Monday. However, it became clear from radio
communications that the couple was in trouble.
The plane took off from Destin-Fort Walton Beach airport at 12:44
p.m., and was scheduled to arrive at Sumner Regional Airport in Gallatin
at 3:34 p.m., according to FlightAware, a website that tracks flights.
The flight’s path shows it reversed direction somewhere over northern
Alabama and began heading south. It crashed in Cullman County about 55
miles north of Birmingham.
On Tuesday, friends remembered a couple that worked hard at their church and other philanthropic organizations.
“They just enjoyed opening their life and home up to other people,”
said the Rev. Bruce Chesser, the senior pastor of First Baptist
Hendersonville where the Cohens attended church. “I see them with their
arms around each other and both with great big smiles on their faces.”
Gary Cohen was an orthodontist at Smiles Under Construction, which
has its main office in Hendersonville. Nancy Cohen was a pharmacist at
Perkins Drugs in Gallatin for 12 years, according to former owner
Ferrell Haile.
Gary Cohen spent many Sunday mornings in a golf cart, shuttling
churchgoers from their cars to First Baptist Hendersonville’s worship
center, Chesser said. Nancy Cohen helped lead Bible studies and Sunday
school sessions, said friend Judy Sindle.
In a congregation of about 8,000, Chesser said, the pair was widely known and respected.
They also supported other community organizations, he said, including the Tennessee Baptist Children’s Homes.
The Cohens’ work for others had a sturdy spiritual foundation, according to Sindle.
“It was all centered around their commitment to their church and to God.”
The Cohens are survived by three adult children and two grandchildren, Sindle said.
http://www.tennessean.com
IDENTIFICATION
Regis#: 1085A Make/Model: MO20 Description: M20M
Date: 09/17/2012 Time: 1859
Event Type: Accident Highest Injury: Fatal Mid Air: N Missing: N
Damage: Destroyed
LOCATION
City: JASPER State: AL Country: US
DESCRIPTION
AIRCRAFT CRASHED UNDER UNKNOWN CIRCUMSTANCES, THE 2 PERSONS ON BOARD WERE
FATALLY INJURED, NEAR JASPER, AL
INJURY DATA Total Fatal: 2
# Crew: 2 Fat: 2 Ser: 0 Min: 0 Unk:
# Pass: 0 Fat: 0 Ser: 0 Min: 0 Unk:
# Grnd: Fat: 0 Ser: 0 Min: 0 Unk:
OTHER DATA
Activity: Unknown Phase: Unknown Operation: OTHER
FAA FSDO: BIRMINGHAM, AL (SO09) Entry date: 09/18/2012
http://flightaware.com/live/flight/N1085A
http://registry.faa.gov/N1085A
The plane crashed off of CR 174 in the Crane Hill Community near Smith Lake.
Source: Christy Hutchings
~
Authorities work the scene of a plane crash Monday afternoon in Cullman County. Reports indicate there were no survivors.
Police direct traffic near the site of the plane crash in western Cullman County.
(Photo: Matt Kroschel, WHNT News 19)
ABC 33/40 - Birmingham News, Weather, Sports
http://flightaware.com/live/flight/N1085A
http://registry.faa.gov/N1085A
Hendersonville orthodontist Gary
Cohen and his wife, Nancy, were killed Monday in a plane crash in
Alabama as they were flying back to Gallatin, the couple’s pastor
confirmed Tuesday.
Nancy
Cohen, 60, worked as a pharmacist at Perkins Drugs in Gallatin for 12
years, according to former owner Ferrell Haile, who retired in January.
“She
was such an asset to our patients,” Haile said. “She was compassionate,
but she also knew how to have fun. They both had a strong faith they
lived and walked.”
According to the Cullman (Ala.) Times, a
small, single-engine plane crashed in southwest Cullman County, Ala.,
Monday afternoon, killing both the pilot and a single passenger. No one
on the ground was injured.
The plane, a Mooney M20
single-propeller aircraft, went down in a pasture less than a mile from a
residential area, the newspaper reported. Severe weather was reported
in the area shortly before 2:30 p.m., when the crash occurred. The news
outlet also reported Federal Aviation Administration investigators
arrived at the scene about two hours after the crash and that an
official with the National Transportation Safety Board is expected to
visit today.
The plane took off from Destin-Fort Walton Beach
airport in Destin, Fla., at 12:44 p.m. and was scheduled to arrive at
Sumner Regional Airport in Gallatin at 3:34 p.m., according to
FlightAware, a website that tracks flights. The flight’s path shows it
reversed direction somewhere over northern Alabama and began heading
south.
FAA records show the plane is registered to SC Leasing
LLC. That entity is owned by the Cohens, who kept the plane in a hangar
at the Gallatin airport, said Sumner County Regional Airport
Administrator Steve Sudbury.
Sudbury said he knew Gary Cohen to be a “perfectionist” and a “very meticulous person,” especially when it came to his plane.
“It’s
a sad day for aviation in the Sumner community; we don’t have many
plane crashes,” he said. “Gary was a great guy, very personable, always
had a smile on his face.”
Cohen had filed a flight plan, Sudbury
said, so airport officials knew to expect him Monday. However, it became
clear from radio communications that the couple was in trouble.
“He
was in contact with the Atlanta tower and evidently, at some point
after the first point of notification, later called in a mayday,” he
said.
The Cohens’ pastor, Bruce Chesser, of First Baptist Church
in Hendersonville, asked church members in an email Tuesday to pray for
the three children of the couple.
“We have many, many deaths in
our church family and they are all equally significant. But this is such
an unusual situation to have husband and wife both killed so
tragically,” he wrote.
A spokesperson for Cullman County, Ala.,
Coroner Steve Rogers said it may be Wednesday before the victims are
officially identified. The city of Cullman is about 55 miles north of
Birmingham.
Chesser said the couple was returning from a weekend trip in Destin, Fla., and that their deaths shook the community.
“The
shock of healthy, vibrant people their age – the death of both –
there’s where the punch in the gut to the community comes from,” he
said.
A note was posted Tuesday on the front door of Gary Cohen’s
main office in Hendersonville: “Out of respect for Dr. Cohen’s family,
friends and staff, we are asking that all news media refrain from coming
into the building. We appreciate your concern, but please allow us to
grieve!”
Smiles Under Construction, where Cohen, 61, was an orthodontist, also has locations in Gallatin and White House.
The Gallatin News Examiner will have more on this breaking story as it unfolds.
CULLMAN COUNTY, AL - The Cullman County Sheriff's Office
has confirmed that two people are dead after a plane crashed
near Smith Lake Monday afternoon.
The Sheriff's Office says the plane went down
off of County Road 174 near the Crane Hill community. Sheriff's
deputies and local fire department officials are on the scene now.
The FAA reports that a Mooney 20 aircraft
with two people on board crashed around 2 p.m. today. The plane was
flying from Destin, Fla. to the Sumner County Airport in Gallatin, Tenn.
The identities of the two people killed in the crash have not yet been
released by officials.
This crash is the third deadly plane crash in Alabama in the past three days.
Saturday, a pilot named William Shaver crashed into Weiss Lake in Cherokee County.
Shaver was the only person on board the aircraft and was flying from
Guntersville to visit friends in the area. Officials say Shaver was
trying to land when he clipped a main power line and crashed into the
lake. He did not survive.
Two people also died in a plane crash in Madison County
on Sunday near the Moontown Airport in Brownsboro, Tenn. The pilot of
the plane, George Myers, 74, and a 17-year-old passenger named Christian
Schmitt were killed in the crash.
Check back for more details on this developing story.
CULLMAN, Alabama -- The pilot of a single engine airplane that crashed, killing two people, called out a mayday before it went down near Smith Lake, according to the Cullman County Sheriff's Office.
Mark Persall, deputy in administration at the Cullman County Sheriff's Office, said that according to the Federal Aviation Administration the Mooney 20 airplane was out of Destin, Fla., and was in contact with the FAA's tower in Atlanta as the plane headed to Gallatin, Tenn. Before the crash the pilot radioed that there were difficult weather conditions and called in a mayday, he said.
Heavy rains did pass through Cullman County this afternoon, Persall said.
The plane crashed near Smith Lake in the Ardell community, which is near Crane Hill, Persall said. "It's a fairly large debris field," he said.
The FAA and National Transportation Safety Board, which investigate fatal aircraft crashes has been notified, Persall said.
Story and comments: http://blog.al.com
VINEMONT, Ala. (AP) - Authorities say an airplane crash in Cullman County has killed two people.
Mark Persall, the administrative chief of Cullman
County Sheriff's Department, says a small, blue & white plane went
down about 2:20 p.m. Monday near a county road.
Persall says air traffic controllers from Atlanta
were monitoring the aircraft when it developed problems. Persall says
controllers report that the pilot talked about being in bad weather
before losing contact.
Storms with heavy rains were moving across the region at the time.
Officials say the flight didn't originate at Cullman County's airport, and it apparently wasn't headed there.
Authorities haven't released the names of the victims.
http://www.myfoxal.com
CULLMAN —
Authorities have confirmed that a small, single-engine plane has crashed
in Cullman County just off Co. Rd. 174 near Smith Lake.
Authorities believe there were 1-2 occupants inside the plane, and responders at the scene report there were no survivors.
The
crash occurred in an overgrown field at approximately 2:20 p.m.. Debris
is spread out approximately 80-yards from the initial impact zone.
Authorities say the plane was being tracked from
Birmingham on radar when it crashed.
Officials from the FAA are en route to the scene.
http://www.cullmantimes.com
