Wednesday, August 7, 2019

Powerplant System / Component Malfunction / Failure: Robinson R44 Astro, N981RR; accident occurred May 05, 2017 in Santa Barbara, California

The National Transportation Safety Board traveled to the scene of this accident.

Additional Participating Entities:

Federal Aviation Administration / Flight Standards District Office; Van Nuys, California
Lycoming Engines; Williamsport, Pennsylvania
Robinson Helicopter Company; Torrance, California

Aviation Accident Factual Report - National Transportation Safety Board: https://app.ntsb.gov/pdf


Investigation Docket - National Transportation Safety Board: https://dms.ntsb.gov/pubdms


http://registry.faa.gov/N981RR


Location: Santa Barbara, CA
Accident Number: WPR17LA097
Date & Time: 05/05/2017, 1402 PDT
Registration: N981RR
Aircraft: ROBINSON HELICOPTER R44
Aircraft Damage: Destroyed
Defining Event: Powerplant sys/comp malf/fail
Injuries: 3 Serious
Flight Conducted Under: Part 91: General Aviation - Personal - Sightseeing 

On May 5, 2017, at 1402 Pacific daylight time, a Robinson R44 helicopter, N981RR, lost engine power and landed hard following an autorotation near Santa Barbara, California. The flight instructor and two passengers sustained serious injuries, and the helicopter was destroyed by post impact fire. The helicopter was registered to Spitzer Helicopter LLC, and operated by Santa Barbara Helicopter Tours, as a revenue sightseeing flight under the provisions of Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed, and no flight plan had been filed. The local flight departed Santa Barbara Municipal Airport, Santa Barbara, California, about 1345.

The flight was planned to be a standard 20 minute, "City Tour" for the two passengers, which included a roundtrip flight from the airport to the Santa Barbara Zoo area, about 10 miles east.

The outbound flight was uneventful with the pilot requesting a special VFR (visual flight rules) clearance due to low cloud ceilings. On the return leg, the weather had not improved, and the pilot requested a special VFR clearance to land. The airport controllers directed the pilot to hold outside of the airport's airspace due to landing traffic, and the pilot circled the city for about 10 minutes until the landing request was granted. He then proceeded to follow the 101 Highway west towards the airport, and a brief time later he noticed that the engine began to lose partial power, coincident with the clutch actuator light illuminating. He pulled the clutch actuator circuit breaker while evaluating his landing options. He began to maneuver the helicopter for landing at a golf course, rather than the highway or congested areas below, and a few seconds later the engine lost all power.

He immediately initiated an autorotation, with the intention of landing on the golf course. During the final stage of the descent, he realized he would not be able to reach the grass due to a wall, so he landed just short in a parking lot. During the landing flare, the helicopter's main rotor blades struck the roof of a building, and the helicopter landed hard, spreading both skids (See Figure 1). All occupants egressed from the helicopter, while the golf course superintendent, who heard the impact, attempted to extinguish a fire which had developed at the rear of the helicopter's fuselage. Within a few minutes the fire had spread, ultimately engulfing the main cabin as the local fire department arrived about 5 minutes later.

Multiple witnesses reported seeing an object fall from the helicopter as it flew over the highway, and post-accident examination revealed that the engines number 3 cylinder head assembly and piston were missing (See Figure 2). A search was conducted by volunteer search and rescue personnel from the Santa Barbara County Sherriff's Department, and the assembly was located the following day, in a field about 1/4 mile north of the wreckage location (See Figure 3).


Figure 1 - Helicopter at the Accident Site

Figure 2 - Helicopter at the Accident Site with Cylinder #3 Missing

Figure 3 - Cylinder #3 

Pilot Information

Certificate: Flight Instructor; Commercial
Age: 40, Male
Airplane Rating(s): Single-engine Land
Seat Occupied: Right
Other Aircraft Rating(s): Helicopter
Restraint Used:
Instrument Rating(s): Helicopter
Second Pilot Present: No
Instructor Rating(s): Helicopter
Toxicology Performed: No
Medical Certification: Class 2 Without Waivers/Limitations
Last FAA Medical Exam: 02/22/2017
Occupational Pilot: Yes
Last Flight Review or Equivalent: 02/22/2017
Flight Time:  1520 hours (Total, all aircraft), 944 hours (Total, this make and model), 1419 hours (Pilot In Command, all aircraft), 98 hours (Last 90 days, all aircraft), 20 hours (Last 30 days, all aircraft), 1 hours (Last 24 hours, all aircraft)

Aircraft and Owner/Operator Information

Aircraft Make: ROBINSON HELICOPTER
Registration: N981RR
Model/Series: R44
Aircraft Category: Helicopter
Year of Manufacture: 2001
Amateur Built: No
Airworthiness Certificate: Normal
Serial Number: 0961
Landing Gear Type: Ski;
Seats: 4
Date/Type of Last Inspection: 04/06/2017, Continuous Airworthiness
Certified Max Gross Wt.: 2200 lbs
Time Since Last Inspection: 36.5 Hours
Engines: 1 Reciprocating
Airframe Total Time: 3709 Hours at time of accident
Engine Manufacturer: LYCOMING
ELT: Not installed
Engine Model/Series: O-540
Registered Owner: SPITZER HELICOPTER LLC
Rated Power: 260 hp
Operator: Santa Barbara Helicopter Tours
Operating Certificate(s) Held: Commercial Air Tour (136); On-demand Air Taxi (135)
Operator Does Business As: Santa Barbara Helicopter Tours
Operator Designator Code: 9D3A 



Meteorological Information and Flight Plan

Conditions at Accident Site: Visual Conditions
Condition of Light: Day
Observation Facility, Elevation: KSBA, 20 ft msl
Distance from Accident Site: 5 Nautical Miles
Observation Time: 1353 PDT
Direction from Accident Site: 265°
Lowest Cloud Condition:
Visibility:  10 Miles
Lowest Ceiling: Overcast / 800 ft agl
Visibility (RVR):
Wind Speed/Gusts: 3 knots /
Turbulence Type Forecast/Actual:
Wind Direction: 240°
Turbulence Severity Forecast/Actual:
Altimeter Setting: 29.9 inches Hg
Temperature/Dew Point: 14°C / 12°C
Precipitation and Obscuration: No Obscuration; No Precipitation
Departure Point: SANTA BARBARA, CA (SBA)
Type of Flight Plan Filed: None
Destination: SANTA BARBARA, CA (SBA)
Type of Clearance: Special VFR
Departure Time: 1345 PDT
Type of Airspace: Class C



Wreckage and Impact Information

Crew Injuries: 1 Serious
Aircraft Damage: Destroyed
Passenger Injuries: 2 Serious
Aircraft Fire: On-Ground
Ground Injuries: N/A
Aircraft Explosion: None
Total Injuries: 3 Serious
Latitude, Longitude: 34.432778, -119.751111

Tests And Research

Engine Examination

The engine was disassembled following the accident by technical representatives from Lycoming Engines under the supervision of the NTSB investigator-in-charge, and inspectors from the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). Complete examination reports are contained in the public docket, the following is a summary of findings.

The engine remained attached to the aft frame support assembly and the forward engine mounts. It sustained extensive thermal damage, partially consuming most of its ancillary components.

The entire number 3 cylinder assembly had separated from the engine, and neither its pushrods were recovered. The lower section of the crankcase deck adjacent to the underside of cylinder 3, along with the entire oil sump was consumed by fire.

The crankshaft could be viewed through the opening, and was intact. The number 3 connecting rod remained attached to the crankshaft, and protruded from the opening. The outboard (piston) end of the rod was not present.

The engine was examined for evidence of signatures typically associated with overspeed, as defined in Lycoming Service Bulletin SB369N. The valves, springs, and rocker arm assemblies for each cylinder were intact and undamaged. The valves slid easily out of their valve guides, and did not exhibit any indications of valve head "mushrooming" or burs to the areas in contact with the valve keys. The valve keys and exhaust valve caps were all undamaged, and the remaining pushrods were straight. The camshaft was intact, and all lobes and bearing surfaces were shiny in appearance and free of score marks.

The oil filter had sustained thermal damage and was removed from the housing and disassembled. The filter element was black and charred, and contained bronze-colored non-ferrous metallic debris similar in appearance to connecting rod (piston-end) bushing material.



Materials Laboratory Examination

The engine crankcase, 6 connecting rod wrist pins, 12 wrist pin plugs, the through bolts, main crankshaft bearings, and the number 3 and 4 cylinder and piston assemblies were sent to the NTSB Materials Laboratory for examination.

Examination revealed that the number 3 cylinder attachment studs and throughbolts all exhibited varying combinations and degrees of necking damage, smearing deformation, and rough and matte gray fracture features, all of which were consistent with ductile overstress.

The damaged number 3 connecting rod had fractured just short of the bushing, which was missing. The corresponding piston was mostly intact, and the wrist pin was in place. The piston had multiple impact marks on the underside surfaces and piston skirt. The skirt was deformed inward at the forward and aft sides, trapping the piston within the cylinder barrel.

A segment of the upper side of the piston skirt was fractured and missing, and a similar shaped segment of the skirt at the lower side of the barrel was fractured and flattened against the cylinder attachment flange. The damage to both segments was consistent with contact with the number 3 connecting rod.

At the upper side of the cylinder flange, the attachment holes were elongated. The location of the hole elongation was consistent with the direction of shear deformation observed in the corresponding studs. At the lower side of the cylinder, the flange was bent, and cracked though the middle two attachment holes. The cracks were associated with deformation consistent with ductile overstress fracture.

Most of the number 3 cylinder attachment flange around the attachment holes appeared dark gray, but portions of the flange were either coated in an orange oxidized layer, or appeared light gray and smeared. Machining marks were visible around most of the surfaces, including many of the oxidized areas.

The crankcase was separated to reveal the mating sides of the crankcase halves. The mating surfaces had a smooth, polished appearance with scattered pits. Similar pit features were also observed on other machined surfaces including the saddle surfaces supporting the main journal bearings and the camshaft journal bore surfaces.

The connecting rod for cylinder 3 was fractured where the wrist pin bore intersected the beam section of the rod. A curved impact mark was observed on the outboard end of the connecting rod. The shape of the impact mark was consistent with the inboard end of the cylinder barrel skirt at the "6 o'clock" position. The rod end surfaces were obliterated by post-fracture contact damage, and fine features of the fractures were mostly obliterated by oxidation. Remaining fracture surfaces were visually smooth with sliding contact marks, consistent with ductile overstress fracture in compressive shear loading. Elongated dimple features were observed on remaining fracture surfaces, also consistent with ductile overstress fracture.

The outboard ends of the number 2, 4, and 6 connecting rods had a bright blue color, and a slight blue tint was also noted at the outboard ends of connecting rods 1 and 5.

The wrist pins from cylinders 1, 2, 4, 5, and 6 were mostly free of mechanical damage, but were tinted brown, bluish gray, and black consistent with heat exposure. By comparison, the number 3 wrist pin had mechanical damage in the area corresponding to the connecting rod attachment and was light gray in color across most of the surface. Bushings in three of the connecting rods had shifted out of position laterally, and in two cases, the bushing split line had rotated from its installed position by about 45o.

Examination of the inboard and outboard surfaces of the number 3 wrist pin revealed a bluish gray circumferential tint band on one side where it intersected the boss on the piston, and a brown circumferential tint band adjacent to the other boss. Circumferential gouges and galling were present on the surface between the two tint bands. A longitudinal mark with galled material was present on the outboard side of the wrist pin.

Maintenance History

According to the last entry in the maintenance records on April 6, 2017, the engine had accumulated 1,473 hours of flight time since a Lycoming factory rebuild in 2011. The engine tachometer was destroyed in the fire, but according to the operator, the helicopter had accumulated an additional 36.5 hours during that time.

The records indicated that the oil system was serviced in accordance with Lycoming Engines Mandatory Service Bulletin SB-480E, which required oil changes at 50-hour intervals along with a check for premature or excessive engine component wear, indicated by the presence of metal particles, shavings, or flakes in the oil filter element or screens. The last oil change took place on April 1, 2017, 39.8 hours before the accident, and the logbook entry specifically noted that the oil filter and screens were examined at that time.

SB-480E stated that Lycoming encourages the use of spectrograph oil analysis to monitor engine component wear rates.

No oil from the engine was ever sent for spectrographic analysis, and there was no evidence to indicate the connecting rods or connecting rod bushings were changed since the engine was rebuilt.

Maintenance Bulletins and Directives

Lycoming Engines Mandatory Service Bulletin SB-630, subject, "Connecting Rod Bushing Inspection After Cylinder Removal" was issued about one month before the accident on April 10, 2017. It applied to all Lycoming engines, and required the inspection of the connecting rod bushing for indications that it had shifted out of position. Compliance was mandated at the next maintenance event that required cylinder removal.

Mandatory Service Bulletin SB-632, subject, "Identification of Connecting Rods with Non-Conforming Small End Bushings" was issued July 17, 2017 and subsequently updated to SB-632B on August 4, 2017. The bulletin called for identification and replacement of connecting rod bushings. Compliance was required within 10 hours of engine operation; however, the accident engine was not one of the models affected by the bulletin. The FAA mandated compliance with SB-632B by issuing Airworthiness Directive AD 2017-16-11, on August 15, 2017.

According to Airworthiness Bulletin AWB 85-020 Issue 3, issued by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority of Australia (CASA), all Lycoming reciprocating aircraft engines which were new, factory rebuilt, or factory overhauled during the 2011 calendar year were susceptible to premature wear of the connecting rod bushings. The bulletin noted that in both those engines, and all engines referenced in SB-632B, one or more bushings may shift axially during operation, leading to wear of the protruding edge of the bushing against the piston. The bulletin further stated that the development of this premature wear condition is relatively slow and predictable, and that regular oil and oil filter inspections have shown to be effective in detecting this condition.

Representatives from Lycoming Engines stated that they had no evidence to corroborate the findings of AWB 85-020 regarding 2011 calendar year engines. Specifically, that there were no changes to systems, process, or materials that would explain the failures related to 2011-year engines operating in Australia. Furthermore, the FAA did not find evidence that would have necessitated the release of a similar directive in the United States.

The helicopter was fitted with the fuel tank bladders required in Robinson Helicopters Service Bulletin SB-78B

No comments: